How to Select the Right Battery for Your Application? Part 2: Common Primary Battery Chemistries

Posted by Vidyu Challa on Jan 27, 2017 9:37:00 AM

Battery selectionIn part 1 of this 3-part blog series, we discussed the most important metrics for battery selection. One thing to remember about battery selection is that it is essentially about managing tradeoffs. You trade off one feature in order to gain in another – for example in order to gain power density, you may have to reduce energy density.

In this and a subsequent blog post, we will discuss one of the most important aspects governing battery selection – battery cell chemistry. Many important cell properties such as energy density, flammability and safety, available cell constructions, temperature range and shelf life are dictated by battery chemistry. So, let’s take a look at the most common primary battery chemistries available.

Some common Primary battery chemistries include 

a) Zinc-carbon batteries have been around for more than 100 years. These are low cost and are available in many shapes and sizes. However, they have lost market share to newer chemistries in the past few decades. They are still used in low drain intermittent use applications like remote controls, flashlights and clocks.  

Cross section of a zinc-carbon batteryFigure 1: Cross-section of a zinc–carbon battery.

b) Alkaline Zinc batteries were invented by Lewis Urry while he was employed by Eveready Battery Company. They provide higher rate capability and improved shelf life compared to Zinc carbon batteries. Urry’s innovations included replacing the Zin can (Figure 1) by powdered Zinc, massively increasing the surface area and improving discharge rate capability. He also replaced the acidic electrolyte with KOH, further decreasing internal resistance and improving rate capability. Urry demonstrated his invention to his boss by racing two toy cars in the factory cafeteria, one with a traditional Zn-carbon D cell, and another with his new battery. The first barely moved, while the second made a few trips along the length of the cafeteria.

Alkaline zinc cells are used in applications where the battery is used intermittently but needs to work reliably and is exposed to uncontrolled storage conditions, such as smoke alarms and watches.

c) Zinc silver oxide batteries have high energy density, long shelf life and flat voltage discharge profiles. They are commonly used in portable and miniature electronic applications such as watches, calculators, hearing aids and toys. They use a zinc anode, a silver oxide cathode and a KOH electrolyte when high power capability is required. A NaOH electrolyte is used if longer shelf life is desired. The high cost of silver mostly limits this chemistry to small batteries, except in space and military applications where cost is less important.

Why zinc silver oxide over lithium ion batteries for miniature electronic applications? The safety issues with pets or kids swallowing small cells that could get lodged in the esophagus presents a nightmare situation for a lithium chemistry. Further owing to the low conductivity of organic electrolytes, lithium chemistry favors larger surface area for high rate capability applications.

d) Zinc Air Batteries are most commonly used in hearing aid applications owing to their high-energy density, ideal voltage for the application and long shelf life until activation. The battery chemistry uses a Zinc anode, a potassium hydroxide electrolyte and air as the cathode. The battery is activated by removing a sealing tab, and air is introduced into the cell. The use of air instead of traditional cathode materials such as metal oxides allows smaller and lighter batteries to be made. Disadvantages include sensitivity to the environment once batteries are activated – they have to be used up quickly.

e) Lithium Primary Batteries - Lithium is the lightest metal in the periodic table and has a specific capacity of 3860 mAh/g compared to Zinc at 820 mAh/g. Lithium also has an electrochemical reduction potential of 3.045 V against 0.76 V for Zinc (i.e a lithium based battery provides a battery voltage of 3 V or greater). The combination of these two properties results in very high energy densities for lithium based batteries.

However, lithium is highly reactive towards water and cannot be used with aqueous electrolytes unlike Zinc. Organic electrolytes are commonly used – but these pale in conductivity compared to aqueous electrolytes like potassium hydroxide, zinc chloride, etc. and limit the power output of lithium batteries (in order to get power, low battery resistance and high electrolyte conductivity are required). On the plus side, the lower freezing points of organic electrolytes allows them to be operated at lower temperature than aqueous electrolyte based battery systems.

Common primary lithium batteries include

Lithium Manganese dioxide batteries use lithium metal as the anode, and a manganese dioxide cathode. These are available in button cell, and cylindrical formats. Owing to the low conductivity of organic electrolytes, Li-MnO2 cell designs favor large surface area cell construction such as coin over button cells and jellyroll construction over the bobbin type in order to minimize internal resistance and enhance power capability.  Lithium coin cells also are operated at lower currents than Zinc silver oxide cells in order to minimize internal resistance and cell heating.

Bobbin Cell Construction Jelly Roll Construction

Figure: Bobbin Cell vs Jelly Roll Construction. The former is optimized for energy, and the latter for power. 

Lithium Iron Sulfide batteries provide a higher energy density alternative to alkaline batteries at 1.5 V with superior performance at high drain rates, longer shelf life, better leak resistance, wider operating temperature range, and a reduction in weight. These cells are used in digital cameras and camcorders. Disadvantages include transportation restrictions due to the lithium metal content in the anode and the higher cost (each airline passenger is restricted to carrying 2 g of metallic lithium in primary batteries, or 8 g of rechargeable Li-ion, which amounts to 2 Lithium iron Sulfide cells). These cells have a PTC safety switch, which acts as a current limiter in case the cell overheats.

Properties for Common Primary Batteries

           Table 1 : Properties for Common Primary Batteries, Reference Linden’s Battery Handbook.

Battery cell chemistry dictates many of the cell properties that impact battery performance, thereby making it a key consideration in battery selection. As a follow up to the primary battery cell chemistry we explored in this blog, our next post will delve into secondary battery chemistries.

To learn more about how battery selection takes on special significance for emerging technologies, watch Wireless Reliability in the Internet of Things (IoT) World. Click the button below to access the webinar presentation and slides.



How To Select The Right Battery For Your Application? Part 1: Important Battery Metric Considerations



How To Select The Right Battery For Your Application? Part 3: Common Secondary Battery Chemistries

Topics: Battery Reliability

Sign me up for updates and offers from ANSYS, including DfR Solutions, and our partners. I can unsubscribe at any time.